Summarized Scar Reducing Treatment Reviews

We summarized what people are saying, online, about various scar reducing treatments, to help you find the best one.
I chose this subject because I managed to get a scar on my left shin, after bumbing into a coffee table, and I wanted to see which treatment for it should, statistically, work best.
The following products are sorted by their average sentiment rating (how much the reviewers seem to like them).
By clicking on the product images, you'll get to that product's page, and see a summary of what people are saying about it.

Aroamas Professional Silicone Scar Sheets

Number of mentions of this product that we found: 100
Average sentiment rating: 94% positive
51 people (51%) said that it works well when used consistently over time | Average rating: 97.4%
37 people (37%) said that it works well on old, nasty, new and surgery scars | Average rating: 99%
23 people (23%) said that you can cut them to fit your scar, and they stick for long time | Average rating: 97.2%
14 people (14%) said that it's easy to use, sticks well and works well | Average rating: 100%
11 people (11%) said that they are eager to see their scars recovering | Average rating: 96.4%
10 people (10%) said that they have seen some improvement and will continue using it for better results | Average rating: 98%
8 people (8%) said that it works well and they are happy with the results | Average rating: 100%
7 people (7%) said that it was recommended by a doctor | Average rating: 91.4%
6 people (6%) said that if you put them back in the plastic they came in, they can be reused several times | Average rating: 96.6%
4 people (4%) said that they come off easily | Average rating: 100%
4 people (4%) said that it lasts long and they only take it out while showering | Average rating: 100%
4 people (4%) said that they blend well with the skin | Average rating: 100%
3 people (3%) said that they highly recommend this product | Average rating: 100%
2 people (2%) said that these strips came off a little because of the scar location | Average rating: 100%
2 people (2%) said that they thought of trying the product and are happy with the results | Average rating: 100%
2 people (2%) said that this is better than other brands | Average rating: 90%
2 people (2%) said that they are hard to unstick | Average rating: 80%
2 people (2%) said that it is as good as the expensive alternatives | Average rating: 100%
2 people (2%) said that they are comfortable to wear for long hours | Average rating: 100%
2 people (2%) said that you can wear them while showering, it won't come off | Average rating: 100%

Aroamas Professional Silicone Scar Removal Sheets for Scars Caused by C-Section

Number of mentions of this product that we found: 100
Average sentiment rating: 92.2% positive
52 people (52%) said that they work well when used consistently over time | Average rating: 98.2%
20 people (20%) said that they are easy to use and stick well in shower | Average rating: 97.2%
18 people (18%) said that you can cut them to fit your scar | Average rating: 100%
18 people (18%) said that they are happy with the results and will continue to use them | Average rating: 100%
18 people (18%) said that they highly recommend this product | Average rating: 100%
16 people (16%) said that this works well on keloid, surgery scars and nasty scars | Average rating: 93.8%
11 people (11%) said that you can reuse them a few times | Average rating: 94.4%
10 people (10%) said that these are comfortable to wear for the whole day or long hours | Average rating: 98%
8 people (8%) said that they thought of trying it and they are amazed by the results | Average rating: 100%
4 people (4%) said that they use additional items to make it stick well | Average rating: 95%
4 people (4%) said that till now the product has worked well | Average rating: 100%
4 people (4%) said that these were recommended to them by a doctor | Average rating: 100%
2 people (2%) said that they will last a long time | Average rating: 100%
2 people (2%) said that they work well when left on over night | Average rating: 100%
2 people (2%) said that they will update their review after using the product for some time | Average rating: 90%
2 people (2%) said that they stick well and blend into the skin so barely visible | Average rating: 100%
2 people (2%) said that they work well but they curl up a little on the edges | Average rating: 80%

WoundVite Dietary Supplement

Number of mentions of this product that we found: 100
Average sentiment rating: 88.8% positive
24 people (24%) said that they are happy that they tried this product | Average rating: 100%
18 people (18%) said that these are highly recommended for surgery scars | Average rating: 100%
4 people (4%) said that you should start taking it a week before the surgery to get best results | Average rating: 100%
4 people (4%) said that its quick healing effect amazed their doctors | Average rating: 100%
4 people (4%) said that the product didn't meet their expectations | Average rating: 65%
4 people (4%) said that It works well when used consistently over time | Average rating: 100%
2 people (2%) said that they decided to try it after reading the reviews | Average rating: 90%
2 people (2%) said that they used it post a tummy tuck surgery | Average rating: 100%
2 people (2%) said that they have purchased this again and are happy with the results | Average rating: 100%

NuvaDermis Silicone Scar Removal Sheets

Number of mentions of this product that we found: 100
Average sentiment rating: 85% positive
29 people (29%) said that they are easy to use, comfortable, can be cut, stick well | Average rating: 97.2%
20 people (20%) said that you can cut them to fit the scar | Average rating: 98%
15 people (15%) said that it works on old, new, large, nasty, surgery scars | Average rating: 97.4%
13 people (13%) said that they will continue to use it to see even better results | Average rating: 100%
8 people (8%) said that they could see the results only after wearing it for a few days | Average rating: 97.4%
6 people (6%) said that it works quickly and can be reused | Average rating: 100%
5 people (5%) said that they will update their review after using it for some more time | Average rating: 72%
4 people (4%) said that they are happy with the results | Average rating: 90%
4 people (4%) said that they blend so well with the skin that you hardly know you are wearing them | Average rating: 90%
2 people (2%) said that they highly recommend this product | Average rating: 90%
2 people (2%) said that you can wear them overnight | Average rating: 100%
2 people (2%) said that these are the best on the market | Average rating: 90%
2 people (2%) said that it worked for them right after the first use | Average rating: 100%

NuvaDermis Scar Removal Cream

Number of mentions of this product that we found: 100
Average sentiment rating: 84% positive
22 people (22%) said that they can see the difference even after a few days | Average rating: 100%
12 people (12%) said that they are eager to see the effects after consistent use over time | Average rating: 91.6%
11 people (11%) said that it works well with consistent usage over time | Average rating: 98.2%
8 people (8%) said that they are happy with the results | Average rating: 95%
6 people (6%) said that it has a light texture and a pleasant smell | Average rating: 80%
4 people (4%) said that they highly recommend this product | Average rating: 100%
4 people (4%) said that it works on stretch marks, burns, insect bites, old, new, large, nasty, surgery scars | Average rating: 100%
3 people (3%) said that a little goes a long way | Average rating: 100%
2 people (2%) said that they decided to try it and are happy with the results | Average rating: 100%
2 people (2%) said that they will post an updated review after some time of using it | Average rating: 90%

Improved Medihoney Gel Wound and & Burn Dressing from Derma Sciences

Number of mentions of this product that we found: 100
Average sentiment rating: 82.4% positive
32 people (32%) said that it works well on various scars, burns, inflammations, surgery marks | Average rating: 98.6%
6 people (6%) said that it was prescribed by a clinic or a doctor | Average rating: 83.4%
4 people (4%) said that it is so small that it looks like a free sample and is very expensive | Average rating: 45%
4 people (4%) said that they highly recommend this product and will buy it again | Average rating: 100%
2 people (2%) said that they bought it for the first time and are not fully satisfied | Average rating: 60%
2 people (2%) said that just a little goes a long way | Average rating: 100%
2 people (2%) said that it works well with consistent use | Average rating: 100%
2 people (2%) said that they decided to try this product and were happy with its results | Average rating: 100%
2 people (2%) said that even though the clinic or the doctor said the product won't work, it works quite well | Average rating: 100%
2 people (2%) said that it is very sticky | Average rating: 60%
2 people (2%) said that it is easily available in stores | Average rating: 90%

AWD Medical Soft Silicone Tape for Scars Removal

Number of mentions of this product that we found: 95
Average sentiment rating: 80.6% positive
8 people (8.42%) said that it sticks well, doesn't curl up, has good adhesion, lasts long, comfortable to wear | Average rating: 87.4%
4 people (4.21%) said that it can be washed and reused | Average rating: 90%
4 people (4.21%) said that they have tried other brands and this is the best of all | Average rating: 100%
4 people (4.21%) said that it works on large, old, nasty, and surgery scars | Average rating: 100%
2 people (2.11%) said that it didn't work as well as they expected | Average rating: 30%
2 people (2.11%) said that this doesn't stick so well | Average rating: 60%
2 people (2.11%) said that it is easy to use, cut to fit the scar, and take off | Average rating: 100%

KELODA Scar & Keloid Removal Tea Tree Oil & Massager

Number of mentions of this product that we found: 96
Average sentiment rating: 80.4% positive
13 people (13.54%) said that it worked on their ear or nose piercing keloid | Average rating: 97%
8 people (8.33%) said that they tried several other remedies but nothing else worked while this product worked really well | Average rating: 97.4%
7 people (7.29%) said that it works in just a few days | Average rating: 97.2%
2 people (2.08%) said that they are happy with the results and will continue to use it till their scar goes away | Average rating: 100%
2 people (2.08%) said that they will buy it again because the product really worked well | Average rating: 100%
2 people (2.08%) said that you need to massage it well a few times a day to see best results | Average rating: 90%

BioCorneum Scar Treatment Plus SPF 30 Silicone Scar Gel 10 Gram By Sientra

Number of mentions of this product that we found: 99
Average sentiment rating: 79% positive
9 people (9.09%) said that it works well on consistent usage over a period of time | Average rating: 100%
8 people (8.08%) said that it was prescribed by a doctor or a clinic and works well | Average rating: 97.4%
5 people (5.05%) said that they like the texture of the cream and a little goes a long way | Average rating: 100%
4 people (4.04%) said that it doesn't work | Average rating: 30%
4 people (4.04%) said that it works well on nasty, large, old, new or surgery scars | Average rating: 100%

Kelo-cote Advanced Skincare Formula Scar Gel

Number of mentions of this product that we found: 93
Average sentiment rating: 77% positive
31 people (33.33%) said that it works well with consistent use over time | Average rating: 94.8%
12 people (12.9%) said that it works well on surgery scars | Average rating: 90%
5 people (5.38%) said that they are happy with the results but the tube is too small for the price | Average rating: 68%
4 people (4.3%) said that it works very well on pretty bad keloid | Average rating: 100%
3 people (3.23%) said that you only need to apply a very thin layer of the product | Average rating: 86.6%
2 people (2.15%) said that they are not sure if it's the product or their natural healing that is reducing the scars | Average rating: 60%
2 people (2.15%) said that a little goes a long way | Average rating: 100%
2 people (2.15%) said that it was recommended by a doctor | Average rating: 100%
2 people (2.15%) said that it doesn't work and it is pricy | Average rating: 40%

AWD Medical Grade Soft Silicone Gel Tape for Scar Removal

Number of mentions of this product that we found: 100
Average sentiment rating: 76.4% positive
13 people (13%) said that you can cut it into strips to fit your scars | Average rating: 98.4%
12 people (12%) said that it sticks well and lasts long | Average rating: 83.4%
6 people (6%) said that it works on surgery scars, old and nasty scars, and new scars | Average rating: 93.4%
6 people (6%) said that it seems to be working, will take more time to show results | Average rating: 96.6%
4 people (4%) said that It doesn't stay on | Average rating: 40%
4 people (4%) said that it blends with the skin and sticks well, even in the shower | Average rating: 95%
4 people (4%) said that it's easy to apply and stays in place for days | Average rating: 95%
3 people (3%) said that It works well when used consistently over time | Average rating: 93.4%
2 people (2%) said that they are not sure if it works | Average rating: 50%
2 people (2%) said that they will buy it again | Average rating: 90%
2 people (2%) said that it is very comfortable to wear | Average rating: 70%
2 people (2%) said that it doesn't work | Average rating: 20%
2 people (2%) said that you can reuse it | Average rating: 90%
2 people (2%) said that they would update their review after some time to show results | Average rating: 100%
2 people (2%) said that it comes in good quantity | Average rating: 100%

ScarAway Advanced Skincare Silicone Scar Sheets for C-Sections

Number of mentions of this product that we found: 100
Average sentiment rating: 76.4% positive
20 people (20%) said that they see improvements in their scar so they feel the product works | Average rating: 97.8%
7 people (7%) said that works on old, large, and surgery scars | Average rating: 97.2%
6 people (6%) said that they wash them and reuse them | Average rating: 90%
2 people (2%) said that they feel that they will undertake the complete process and expect good results | Average rating: 100%
2 people (2%) said that this doesn't work so well for their c section or other scars | Average rating: 20%
2 people (2%) said that they decided to try the product and are satisfied with the results | Average rating: 90%
2 people (2%) said that they adjusted the strip length to fit their scar | Average rating: 100%
2 people (2%) said that they had issues with applying these | Average rating: 30%
2 people (2%) said that this is a waste of money | Average rating: 20%
2 people (2%) said that these stick well | Average rating: 100%
2 people (2%) said that these are better than the alternatives | Average rating: 90%
2 people (2%) said that they are easy to apply | Average rating: 100%
2 people (2%) said that they had to buy this product after researching about it | Average rating: 100%

Mederma PM Intensive Overnight Scar Cream

Number of mentions of this product that we found: 100
Average sentiment rating: 75.6% positive
56 people (56%) said that it works well with consistent usage over time | Average rating: 97.4%
15 people (15%) said that it works on old, nasty, new, large, or surgery scars | Average rating: 100%
4 people (4%) said that they highly recommend this product | Average rating: 100%
4 people (4%) said that it does not work | Average rating: 35%
3 people (3%) said that they apply it overnight for good results | Average rating: 86.6%
2 people (2%) said that they are happy that they found this product | Average rating: 100%
2 people (2%) said that it works well on the face and other body parts | Average rating: 100%
2 people (2%) said that they were excited to use the product and see great results but it didn't work out for them | Average rating: 30%
2 people (2%) said that they are not sure of whether the product works or not | Average rating: 50%

bioCorneum Plus SPF 30 Advanced Scar Supervision

Number of mentions of this product that we found: 100
Average sentiment rating: 75.4% positive
11 people (11%) said that it was recommended by a doctor or a clinic | Average rating: 94.6%
4 people (4%) said that they don't see much improvement even after consistent use for a while | Average rating: 60%
4 people (4%) said that there are differences in what you buy at a doctor's office and what you get in the market | Average rating: 90%
4 people (4%) said that it works well on various scars and surgery marks | Average rating: 100%
2 people (2%) said that you need to spread it well and let it dry | Average rating: 60%
2 people (2%) said that it is expensive | Average rating: 70%
2 people (2%) said that they are not sure if the product works or not | Average rating: 60%

Mederma Scar Cream Plus SPF 30

Number of mentions of this product that we found: 100
Average sentiment rating: 72.6% positive
18 people (18%) said that they have used it for a while and are happy with it | Average rating: 97.8%
7 people (7%) said that they are happy with its results and will continue applying it | Average rating: 94.2%
4 people (4%) said that it works well, they are happy with the results and they recommend the product | Average rating: 100%
4 people (4%) said that the size is smaller than what they paid for it | Average rating: 40%
4 people (4%) said that it works well if applied consistently over time | Average rating: 100%
2 people (2%) said that they used it to protect their scar from sun and it works | Average rating: 100%
2 people (2%) said that they recommend this product | Average rating: 90%
2 people (2%) said that they feel they should have checked the package before buying it | Average rating: 50%
2 people (2%) said that they bought an alternative, which works better than this product | Average rating: 20%
2 people (2%) said that it didn't work for them | Average rating: 20%

Sinclair Kelo-Cote Gel for Scars 15g

Number of mentions of this product that we found: 98
Average sentiment rating: 72.6% positive
8 people (8.16%) said that it doesn't work even after consistent use for a while | Average rating: 37.4%
2 people (2.04%) said that the package was broken and labels were fake | Average rating: 20%
2 people (2.04%) said that they bought it for their children and it works well | Average rating: 100%

Cicatricure Face & Body Scar Gel

Number of mentions of this product that we found: 74
Average sentiment rating: 72.4% positive
14 people (18.92%) said that it works well | Average rating: 91.4%
7 people (9.46%) said that they have been consistently applying it but the effect is just fine | Average rating: 62.8%
5 people (6.76%) said that you have to use it 4 times a day and consistently over time | Average rating: 72%
2 people (2.7%) said that it has a nice texture | Average rating: 80%
2 people (2.7%) said that it works on acne scars | Average rating: 100%

ScarAway Advanced Skincare Long Silicone Scar Sheets for Hypertrophic Scars and Keloids Caused by Surgery

Number of mentions of this product that we found: 99
Average sentiment rating: 72.2% positive
5 people (5.05%) said that they can be washed and reused | Average rating: 100%
4 people (4.04%) said that it can curl up if the plastic backing is removed | Average rating: 90%
3 people (3.03%) said that they are not sure if the product works | Average rating: 53.4%
3 people (3.03%) said that you need to wash them properly otherwise you can't reuse them | Average rating: 60%
2 people (2.02%) said that they work when applied consistently over time | Average rating: 80%
2 people (2.02%) said that works on large, old, nasty, new, or surgery scars | Average rating: 100%
2 people (2.02%) said that works well if you follow the directions | Average rating: 100%
2 people (2.02%) said that they couldn't wear it for more than 12 hours at a stretch | Average rating: 50%
2 people (2.02%) said that it works for them | Average rating: 100%
2 people (2.02%) said that they work and are comfortable to wear | Average rating: 70%
2 people (2.02%) said that it exerts the right amount of pressure on the scar | Average rating: 100%
2 people (2.02%) said that they don't stick well | Average rating: 40%
2 people (2.02%) said that it works but needs you to be a little careful with it | Average rating: 100%
2 people (2.02%) said that it didn't work out for them | Average rating: 20%
2 people (2.02%) said that it is easy to apply | Average rating: 40%
2 people (2.02%) said that it is a waste of money | Average rating: 20%

ScarAway Advanced Skincare Silicone Scar Sheets

Number of mentions of this product that we found: 100
Average sentiment rating: 70.4% positive
20 people (20%) said that they have used it for a while and are happy with it | Average rating: 92.8%
11 people (11%) said that they don't stick well | Average rating: 31%
8 people (8%) said that they stick well | Average rating: 95%
7 people (7%) said that it works on the scars from the sutures or surgery | Average rating: 100%
4 people (4%) said that they had to use additional tape or band aid to keep it in place | Average rating: 70%
4 people (4%) said that they tried it and it works | Average rating: 100%
4 people (4%) said that it is easy to apply and remove | Average rating: 90%
2 people (2%) said that the product doesn't come with a storage box | Average rating: 80%
2 people (2%) said that it can last for a few days or a week | Average rating: 70%
2 people (2%) said that if you wash and dry them you can reuse them for several days | Average rating: 100%
2 people (2%) said that it covers the scar well and prevents from more damage | Average rating: 100%
2 people (2%) said that they highly recommend this product | Average rating: 100%
2 people (2%) said that if you wear it for long, it leaves band aid like marks on the skin | Average rating: 70%
2 people (2%) said that it was recommended to them by a doctor and it works well | Average rating: 100%
2 people (2%) said that these don't stick well if reused | Average rating: 60%
2 people (2%) said that it flattens out a bumpy scar and works well | Average rating: 80%

Mederma Advanced Scar Gel

Number of mentions of this product that we found: 100
Average sentiment rating: 68.8% positive
26 people (26%) said that it shows results after consistent use over a period of time | Average rating: 93.8%
7 people (7%) said that they decided to try it after doing some research or reading the reviews | Average rating: 100%
6 people (6%) said that they didn't see results after consistent use for a while | Average rating: 40%
4 people (4%) said that they decided to try it on their acne scars | Average rating: 75%
4 people (4%) said that it works on old and bad scars | Average rating: 100%
4 people (4%) said that they recommend this product | Average rating: 100%
4 people (4%) said that it had some side effects on their skin | Average rating: 25%
4 people (4%) said that it is easy to apply, works well, doesn't have odor, is not too sticky or runny, and a little goes a long way | Average rating: 90%
2 people (2%) said that it works better on new scars with immediate application | Average rating: 100%
2 people (2%) said that they feel it will work better on smaller or less deeper scars | Average rating: 60%

Mederma Kids Skin Care for Scars

Number of mentions of this product that we found: 98
Average sentiment rating: 67% positive
18 people (18.37%) said that they followed the application instructions of 3 times a day for 8 weeks and are not happy with the results | Average rating: 40%
8 people (8.16%) said that they have used it for some time and it is working | Average rating: 100%
4 people (4.08%) said that a little goes a long way | Average rating: 90%
2 people (2.04%) said that it works on scars from dog bites | Average rating: 100%
2 people (2.04%) said that it does not work well | Average rating: 20%
2 people (2.04%) said that it leaves a purple stain | Average rating: 50%
2 people (2.04%) said that it is a waste of money | Average rating: 20%

ScarAway 100% Medical-Grade Silicone Scar Gel for Face

Number of mentions of this product that we found: 100
Average sentiment rating: 62% positive
61 people (61%) said that the roller ball doesn't work and you need to squeeze the tube very hard | Average rating: 46.8%
18 people (18%) said that it reduced their scar significantly | Average rating: 99%
15 people (15%) said that you need to squeeze very hard to get the ointment out of the tube | Average rating: 45.4%
4 people (4%) said that they would not want to roll a metal ball on their scar | Average rating: 40%
2 people (2%) said that the product has no effect even after consistent application | Average rating: 40%
2 people (2%) said that it is a waste of money | Average rating: 20%
2 people (2%) said that this is their first experience with the product | Average rating: 90%
2 people (2%) said that they have recently started using it so can't say much about whether the product works or not | Average rating: 40%
2 people (2%) said that they read bad reviews but still bought the product thinking it will work for them | Average rating: 40%
2 people (2%) said that the tube contains very less gel | Average rating: 40%

Embrace Active Scar Defense for New Scars

Number of mentions of this product that we found: 92
Average sentiment rating: 49.8% positive
28 people (30.43%) said that although it says it could last for 10 days but it doesn't stick so well and comes off earlier | Average rating: 38.8%
4 people (4.35%) said that it is a waste of money | Average rating: 25%
2 people (2.17%) said that they had an allergic reaction to the adhesive | Average rating: 70%
2 people (2.17%) said that it is better to watch the instruction video, the written directions are not too helpful | Average rating: 60%
2 people (2.17%) said that they had to figure out how to use the product properly | Average rating: 100%
2 people (2.17%) said that it works well for them and they will continue to use it | Average rating: 100%
2 people (2.17%) said that it works well with consistent usage over time | Average rating: 100%
2 people (2.17%) said that it can last for 10 days | Average rating: 100%
2 people (2.17%) said that they want a refund as they are not happy with the product | Average rating: 20%
2 people (2.17%) said that it is easy to use and works well | Average rating: 100%